Pak-Christian Asylum Seekers Hope UK Appeal Tribunal will lead to Greater Success

Image

London: November 19, 2015. (PCP) The BPCA have been asked to share news of the country guidance case used as a benchmark for Pakistani Christian asylum cases in English Law. The legal teams for AK and SK have asked Christians up and down the country to pray for success in the appeal hearing being held today. They have also challenged supporters to attend the appeal hearing if possible to show solidarity in hope of a more positive result. AK and SK are represented by Wimbledon Solicitors and Shivani Jegarajah of Mansfield Chambers and Sarah Pinder of Goldsmith Chambers who issued this press release: "The country guidance case in respect of Pakistani Christians and risk is due to be heard in the Court of Appeal on Thursday 19th November on an application for permission. The Upper Tribunal published its determination almost a year ago in December 2014 - AK and SK (Christians: risk) Pakistan CG v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2014] UKUT 00569 (IAC) - dismissing the appeals of AK and SK. Permission to appeal was refused by the Upper Tribunal and following the application being made directly to the Court of Appeal, this was listed by the Court for an oral permission hearing on notice to the SSHD. As part of its country guidance, the Upper Tribunal formed the view that despite Christians in Pakistan suffering discrimination, this was not sufficient to form a real of persecution and that unlike the position of Ahmadis, Christians are in general permitted to practice their faith, by attending church, participating in religious activities and having their own schools and hospitals. On the specific facts of AK and SK, evangelism was also focused upon and the Upper Tribunal concluded that someone who seeks to broadcast their faith to strangers so as to encourage them to convert, may find themselves facing a charge of blasphemy and in that way, evangelical Christians face a greater risk than those Christians who are not publicly active. Specifically with regards to women, the Upper Tribunal found that like other women in Pakistan, Christian women in general face discrimination and may be at a heightened risk but again, in the Tribunal’s view, this was not at a sufficient level to amount to persecution and a fact-sensitive approach was crucial to individual case assessments. AK and SK are challenging the Upper Tribunal’s findings as they have been applied to them and in particular, are arguing that the Tribunal has looked at their cases confining their risk assessment to formal activities, which may or may not have been undertaken rather than an assessment of their “self-definition” and “personal transformation” as Evangelical Christians, which is what was required. An analogy might be made with that of a person’s sexuality and the Tribunal has avoided making a finding as to the centrality of AK’s and SK' belief system to their identity. Separately, the All-Party Parliamentary Group on International Freedom of Religion or Belief very recently called for submissions and held a formal hearing in the Houses of Parliament on 10-11 November 2015 - ‘The Plight of Minority Religious or Belief Groups in Pakistan and as Refugees: Addressing Current UK & UNHCR Policy’." Wilson Chowdhry of the BPCA said: "An eventual judgement against the original Home Office decision would force a review of existing policies towards Pakistani Christians. This would improve the success rate of Pak-Christian asylums seekers who currently have a less than 50% chance of success. Let's hope common sense and fairness wins out. Moreover a legal precedent of this nature would ensure future appeals of poor Home Office decisions would be more favourable".

You May Also Like

Image

Christianphobia and Religious Hatred Spark Debate After Karachi Salon Incident. Report by Sardar Mushtaq Gill

Karachi, Pakistan: A seemingly ordinary encounter at a beauty salon in Karachi has ignited a wider debate about Christianophobia, religious hatred

Image

Lahore Court Acquits Another Christian Within a Week Amid Religious Freedom Concerns. Report by Sardar Mushtaq Gill

Lahore, Pakistan: A sessions court in Lahore has acquitted another Christian man within the span of a week in a blasphemy-related case, further dra

Image

Blind Christian Man Acquitted in Blasphemy Case by Lahore Court, Renewing Concerns Over Misuse of Pakistan’s Blasphemy Laws. Report by Sardar Mushtaq Gill

Lahore, Pakistan: In a significant judgment welcomed by Pakistan’s Christian community and human rights advocates, a Lahore Sessions Court ha



"Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation" By Nazir S Bhatti

On demand of our readers, I have decided to release E-Book version of "Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation" on website of PCP which can also be viewed on website of Pakistan Christian Congress www.pakistanchristiancongress.org . You can read chapter wise by clicking tab on left handside of PDF format of E-Book.

nazirbhattipcc@aol.com , pakistanchristianpost@yahoo.com