Muslim leader: Islamic courts are not a solution, but another problem


Islamabad (AsiaNews) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, one of the most authoritative Islamic scholars in Pakistan, contests the proposal to institute Islamic courts in the country`s tribal areas, because "a problem is not solved by creating a larger one". Ghamidi, known for his efforts to modernise Islam, then emphasised that "the law, and not its interpretation, must be sovereign". The scholar`s statement of his position is part of the wide and unusual debate sparked in Pakistan by the law proposed by the interim government of the North-West Frontier Province. This has in fact decided to modify its Islam-influenced judicial system - the Shariah Nizam-e-Adl, approved in 1994 - to introduce the new Qazi Courts, which would replace the secular Supreme Court of Peshawar in cases of judicial recourse. According to some analysts, this decision will separate the tribal areas of Swat, Dir, and Chitral from the rest of the region: these will receive special treatment, based on laws of a religious character. According to the new scheme, in fact, the judges must adhere to the principle of "Islamic perfection", and will be forced to appoint "assistants" for the judicial bench. These will be chosen from among local religious figures. The proposal has been criticised by human rights activists and secular jurists, who maintain that it is an attempt to introduce radical Islam into the country. Ghamidi, a member of the Council of Islamic Ideology, goes even farther: "The government must understand that religious extremism is a scourge that can be fought only with a steady hand, without ceding anything. Conceding the Qazi Courts means failing to punish horrendous crimes, which would certainly be pardoned by men who look to Mohammed through a distorted perspective". 01/28/08

You May Also Like


Pope Francis skips Via Crucis in Rome while tens of thousands pray his meditations

Vatican City: (By Matthew Santucci for CAN) In an apparent last-minute decision, Pope Francis skipped the Way of the Cross ceremony held at Rome&rs


As many as 2,700 American soldiers are guarding ‘Mr. Bone Saw’ illegal rule of Saudi Arabia. By AHMAR MUSTIKHAN

At least 2,700 U.S. soldiers are guarding one of the most despicable de facto rulers ever of the Saudi sheikhdom, Mohammed bin Salman, according to


Pope Francis changes statutes of papal basilica, emphasizing work of canons

Vatican City: (By Matthew Santucci for CNA) Pope Francis on Wednesday issued new regulations for the administration of the papal Basilica of St. Ma

"Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation" By Nazir S Bhatti

On demand of our readers, I have decided to release E-Book version of "Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation" on website of PCP which can also be viewed on website of Pakistan Christian Congress . You can read chapter wise by clicking tab on left handside of PDF format of E-Book. ,